South China Sea南海

Analysis

One sentence with Jakarta: “waters of overlapping claims”

The China–Indonesia joint statement of 9 November 2024, and a commentary from the weeks before it.

For forty years Beijing has offered neighbours “joint development”. In November 2024 it got the idea into a joint statement with Indonesia, in a sentence that says the two countries' claims overlap, in water Indonesia calls its own exclusive economic zone.

The reading

The sentence does two things at once. It announces cooperation, and in announcing it describes the place: “waters where the two countries' claims overlap”. For Beijing, which says its claims overlap the zone Indonesia calls the North Natuna Sea, having that phrase in a text signed by Jakarta is worth more than any project. A joint steering committee and a signed document on joint development at sea follow from it. E97

It came two weeks after an expulsion. In late October 2024 Indonesia's maritime security agency said it had twice driven off a China Coast Guard ship that disturbed a seismic survey in what Jakarta calls the North Natuna Sea. The Chinese spokesperson said the ship was on routine patrol “in waters under China's jurisdiction”. A Chinese analyst told Global Times plainly that jurisdiction there is disputed and claims overlap, and blamed foreign media for amplifying the incident. The joint statement then put the analyst's description into an agreed text. E95 E97

The escape clause is in the same sentence. Cooperation is to proceed “in accordance with each side's prevailing laws and regulations”. Each government can therefore say nothing in its law has been conceded. The timeline on this site records that Chinese sources did not report Jakarta's later clarification of what it had agreed; the Chinese record keeps the sentence and not the gloss. E97

Coast guards are written in. The same point commits the two countries to “institutionalised cooperation” between coast guards, weeks after their coast guards had faced each other. It is the pattern Beijing prefers: an incident, then a mechanism. E97

Chinese analysts count it as a result. Reviewing 2025, Wu Shicun listed “an agreement with Indonesia on joint development in disputed areas of the South China Sea” first among the developments that helped keep the situation stable. The April 2025 readout of the first foreign and defence ministers' meeting, by contrast, does not mention joint development. Whether anything has been developed is not recorded in the texts read here. T8 E64

Why it matters beyond Indonesia. “Shelve disputes, pursue joint development” has been China's offer since the 1980s, and the white paper says it was first made to the Philippines. Until this statement the formula had few written results with any claimant. The Indonesian sentence is the formula's one recent success on paper, with the neighbour whose dispute with China is smallest. S16 E97

The passages

Joint statement, point 9

双方就在两国主张重叠海域开展共同开发合作达成重要共识,一致同意设立政府间联合指导委员会,本着“相互尊重、平等互利、灵活务实、协商一致”的原则,遵照双方各自现行法律和法规,探讨和推进有关合作。

The two sides reached an important consensus on carrying out joint development cooperation in waters where the two countries' claims overlap, and agreed to set up an intergovernmental joint steering committee to explore and advance the cooperation on the principles of “mutual respect, equality and mutual benefit, flexibility and pragmatism, and consensus”, and in accordance with each side's prevailing laws and regulations.

Point 9

双方将积极推进两国海警机制化合作。

The two sides will actively advance institutionalised cooperation between the two countries' coast guards.

Point 13

访问期间,双方签署海上共同开发、渔业、矿产资源、绿色矿产、水利资源、海事安全、合格评定、蓝色经济、住房以及印尼鲜食椰子输华等领域合作文件。

During the visit the two sides signed cooperation documents in fields including joint development at sea, fisheries, mineral resources, green minerals, water resources, maritime safety, conformity assessment, the blue economy, housing, and the export of fresh Indonesian coconuts to China.

Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian, 24 October 2024, as reported

中国海警船系依据国际法和国内法在中国管辖海域开展例行巡航。

The China Coast Guard vessel was conducting a routine patrol in waters under China's jurisdiction in accordance with international law and domestic law.

Ding Duo of the National Institute for South China Sea Studies

中国和印尼虽然在对南海有关海域的管辖权存在争议,权利主张有重叠,但多年来双方在管控海上分歧上做得比较好。

Although China and Indonesia have a dispute over jurisdiction in the relevant waters of the South China Sea and their claims overlap, for many years the two sides have done fairly well at managing differences at sea.

← Taipei's own words, 2015 and now