Between November 2024 and August 2026 Beijing turned physical control of the shoal into a set of domestic legal facts: a measured territorial sea, a protected area, and a named enforcement agency. Each step answered a Philippine one.
The reading
The sequence. Manila passed its Maritime Zones Act on 8 November 2024; Beijing protested the same day and declared baselines around the shoal on 10 November; it deposited them with the United Nations on 2 December. The State Council approved a national nature reserve in September 2025. Manila then drew its own baselines; Beijing declared them void on 31 July 2026 and, the next day, issued the reserve's management rules while the coast guard and the navy drilled offshore. Each Chinese act is dated within days of a Philippine one. S32 S8 S10 S26 S35 S30 E31
Each step does a different legal job. Baselines turn “waters near Huangyan Dao” into a territorial sea with a measurable edge, so that an approaching ship can be said to have “intruded”. The reserve adds a second, inner perimeter of 3,523.67 hectares with a rule that nobody may enter. The management rules name who polices it. After August 2026 a Philippine fishing boat at the shoal is, in Chinese law, inside a territorial sea, inside a protected area, and subject to a named enforcement agency. S8 S28 S30
The reserve is tied to the baselines in its own text. Article 3 of the rules gives the Ministry of Natural Resources, among routine conservation duties, “the protection and management of the territorial sea base points”. A base point is a legal marker, not an ecological one. Its appearance in conservation rules shows that the reserve and the baselines are one project. S30
Enforcement is given to the coast guard, and penalties refer back to the Coast Guard Law. Article 3 assigns supervision and punishment to the China Coast Guard, with Hainan province in support; article 14 lists the Coast Guard Law among the statutes under which violations are punished. Conservation law thus becomes another ground on which the coast guard may act at the shoal. S30 S5
Beijing condemns in Manila the method it uses itself. The 31 July 2026 statement accuses the Philippines of trying to “entrench” the arbitral award through domestic legislation. Beijing's own answer has been domestic legislation and administrative acts: baselines, a reserve, management rules. Both governments are now writing their claims into national law, and each calls the other's law void. S35 S30
The treaty argument. The 2026 statement says Philippine territory was fixed by “a series of international treaties” that never included the shoal. It does not name them. This is an argument about the limits of the Philippines, not about the origin of China's own title, for which the statement relies on the assertion of “continuous, peaceful and effective” exercise of sovereignty. S35
The passages
Chinese as published; the English is this site's rendering. Check the linked original before quoting.
Foreign Ministry on the baselines, 10 November 2024
是中国政府依法加强海洋管理的正常举措
…a normal measure by the Chinese Government to strengthen maritime management in accordance with the law.
Management Measures, article 12
保护区实行严格保护。未经批准禁止捕捞、采矿和采挖珊瑚、珊瑚礁、砗磲等活动以及其他破坏海洋珍稀物种和自然生态系统的活动。除法律、行政法规规定的情形以及因保护管理需要由管理机构组织开展的活动外,任何单位和个人不得进入保护区。
The reserve is under strict protection. Without approval, fishing, mining and the taking of coral, coral reef and giant clams are prohibited, as are other activities that damage rare marine species and natural ecosystems. Except as provided by law or administrative regulation, or for activities organised by the managing body for protection and management, no unit or individual may enter the reserve.
Management Measures, article 3
自然资源部按规定落实保护区管理机构,负责组织保护区勘界、规划审查、自然资源保护利用管理和资产核算、确权登记、领海基点保护管理等。
The Ministry of Natural Resources shall establish the reserve's managing body as prescribed and is responsible for organising the reserve's boundary survey, plan review, management of the protection and use of natural resources and asset accounting, registration of title, and the protection and management of the territorial sea base points.
Management Measures, article 3
中国海警局及有关海警机构在职责范围内对保护区的保护情况进行监督检查,依法查处违法行为。
The China Coast Guard and the relevant coast guard agencies shall, within their remit, supervise and inspect the protection of the reserve and investigate and punish unlawful acts in accordance with the law.
Foreign Ministry statement, 31 July 2026
菲律宾的领土范围已由一系列国际条约所确定,黄岩岛从来不在其中。
The limits of Philippine territory have been fixed by a series of international treaties, and Huangyan Dao has never been within them.
Foreign Ministry statement, 31 July 2026, on the Philippine Maritime Zones Act
妄图以国内立法形式固化非法的“南海仲裁案裁决”
…a vain attempt to entrench the illegal “South China Sea arbitration award” in the form of domestic legislation.