South China Sea南海

Analysis

What the Coast Guard Law allows

The 2021 statute behind the vessels at Huangyan Dao and Ren'ai Jiao, article by article.

The law gives the coast guard police powers, the power to remove foreign structures and expel foreign government ships, and, in defined cases, the use of weapons. It applies in “waters under China's jurisdiction”, which it never defines.

The reading

A police force with a military chain of command. Article 12 gives the coast guard the duties of a maritime police: patrols, guarding “key islands and reefs”, anti-smuggling, fisheries and environmental inspection. Article 83 adds that it carries out “defence operations” on the orders of the Central Military Commission. The same ships do both. This is why, as Hu Bo notes, the regional use of coast guards instead of navies can be called a restraint and still be a show of force. S5 T25

The geographic scope is left blank on purpose or by omission. Every power in the law applies in “waters under China's jurisdiction”. The term is never defined, and the published text gives no coordinates, no reference to the dashed line and no list of zones. Jin Yongming, a Chinese scholar, lists “undefined jurisdictional waters in the Coast Guard Law” among the unclear points of China's position. Whether a given reef is inside the law's reach is therefore settled by the coast guard's own statement that it is. S5 T15

Article 20 reads like a description of a grounded ship, but the law does not say so. The power to dismantle foreign “structures” and “fixed or floating devices” on reefs under Chinese jurisdiction was written in 2021. Chinese statements call the Philippine ship at Ren'ai Jiao “illegally grounded” and object to construction materials reaching it. No Chinese statement read for this site invokes article 20 against the ship; the connection is this site's observation, not Beijing's stated position. S5 S34 E111

Article 21 supplies the vocabulary of 2026. “Forcible expulsion” and “forcible towing away” are the statutory terms for dealing with foreign government vessels that will not leave. On 1 August 2026 the coast guard announced a drill at Huangyan Dao in boarding, blocking and forced towing: the drill rehearsed the article. The coast guard's routine phrase for what it does to Philippine ships, “warned and expelled”, is the lower rung of the same ladder. S5 E31

Weapons: a broad general clause and narrow specific ones. Article 22 permits “all necessary measures, including the use of weapons” whenever sovereignty or jurisdiction is being infringed, with no further condition. Articles 47 and 48 are much narrower: hand-held weapons after a warning in two listed cases, ship-borne weapons for counter-terrorism, serious violence, or when coast guard craft are attacked. The published accounts of incidents with the Philippines describe water cannon, blocking and boarding, which the law treats as measures short of weapons. The gap between the general clause and the specific ones is where the law's real limits are undecided. S5 E87

Temporary zones. Article 25 lets a provincial-level coast guard bureau declare a temporary maritime security zone and bar ships from it, on five grounds that include “protecting marine resources and the ecological environment”. Read with the 2026 rules for the Huangyan Dao nature reserve, which put the coast guard in charge of enforcement, the law already contains the means to close water around a reef for environmental reasons. S5 S30

The passages

Chinese as published; the English is this site's rendering. Check the linked original before quoting.

Article 3

海警机构在中华人民共和国管辖海域(以下简称我国管辖海域)及其上空开展海上维权执法活动,适用本法。

This Law applies to maritime rights-protection and law-enforcement activities carried out by coast guard agencies in the waters under the jurisdiction of the People's Republic of China (“waters under our jurisdiction”) and in the airspace above them.

Article 20

未经我国主管机关批准,外国组织和个人在我国管辖海域和岛礁建造建筑物、构筑物,以及布设各类固定或者浮动装置的,海警机构有权责令其停止上述违法行为或者限期拆除;对拒不停止违法行为或者逾期不拆除的,海警机构有权予以制止或者强制拆除。

Where foreign organisations or individuals, without the approval of China's competent authorities, build structures or install fixed or floating devices of any kind in waters and on islands and reefs under our jurisdiction, the coast guard may order them to stop or to dismantle them within a time limit; if they refuse to stop or do not dismantle them in time, the coast guard may stop them or dismantle them by force.

Article 21

对外国军用船舶和用于非商业目的的外国政府船舶在我国管辖海域违反我国法律、法规的行为,海警机构有权采取必要的警戒和管制措施予以制止,责令其立即离开相关海域;对拒不离开并造成严重危害或者威胁的,海警机构有权采取强制驱离、强制拖离等措施。

Where foreign military vessels, or foreign government vessels used for non-commercial purposes, violate China's laws and regulations in waters under our jurisdiction, the coast guard may take the necessary warning and control measures to stop them and order them to leave at once; where they refuse to leave and cause serious harm or threat, the coast guard may take measures such as forcible expulsion and forcible towing away.

Article 22

国家主权、主权权利和管辖权在海上正在受到外国组织和个人的不法侵害或者面临不法侵害的紧迫危险时,海警机构有权依照本法和其他相关法律、法规,采取包括使用武器在内的一切必要措施制止侵害、排除危险。

When national sovereignty, sovereign rights or jurisdiction are being unlawfully infringed at sea by foreign organisations or individuals, or face an imminent danger of unlawful infringement, the coast guard may, under this Law and other relevant laws and regulations, take all necessary measures, including the use of weapons, to stop the infringement and remove the danger.

Article 47(2): one of two cases in which hand-held weapons may be used after a warning

外国船舶进入我国管辖海域非法从事生产作业活动,拒不服从停船指令或者以其他方式拒绝接受登临、检查,使用其他措施不足以制止违法行为的

…a foreign vessel has entered waters under our jurisdiction to engage illegally in production operations, refuses to obey an order to stop or otherwise refuses boarding and inspection, and other measures are insufficient to stop the unlawful act.

Article 83

海警机构依照《中华人民共和国国防法》、《中华人民共和国人民武装警察法》等有关法律、军事法规和中央军事委员会的命令,执行防卫作战等任务。

Coast guard agencies carry out defence operations and other tasks in accordance with the National Defence Law, the Law on the People's Armed Police, other relevant laws and military regulations, and the orders of the Central Military Commission.

← The claim, sentence by sentence, and what it leaves open Huangyan Dao: how a legal position is built, step by step →