South China Sea南海

Analysis

Close readings of official documents, think-tank reports and scholars' articles. Each says what the text argues, quotes it in the original and in English, and gives this site's reading. The Briefing is different: it is written by machine from the daily news.

America's positioning

What a Chinese think tank counts, what its director argues, and how far analysts stand from the official line on Washington.

Beijing's own texts, read closely

The claim, the laws and the statements, passage by passage.

04Ten years, two statements: what Beijing said in 2016 and what it says nowComparing the government statement of 12 July 2016 with the Foreign Ministry statement of 12 July 2026The claim itself is repeated word for word. What changed is everything around it: the offer of joint development and the line about respecting freedom of navigation are gone, and an accusation against the United States has taken their place.7 passages · 2 texts read05The claim, sentence by sentence, and what it leaves openThe 1958 declaration, the 1992 and 1998 laws and the 2016 statement read togetherBeijing's claim is built from four texts written over fifty-eight years. Each adds a layer, and each leaves one question unanswered: where the waters begin and end.6 passages · 4 texts read06What the Coast Guard Law allowsThe 2021 statute behind the vessels at Huangyan Dao and Ren'ai Jiao, article by articleThe law gives the coast guard police powers, the power to remove foreign structures and expel foreign government ships, and, in defined cases, the use of weapons. It applies in “waters under China's jurisdiction”, which it never defines.6 passages · 1 text read07Huangyan Dao: how a legal position is built, step by stepBaselines, a deposit at the United Nations, a nature reserve and its rules, read as one sequenceBetween November 2024 and August 2026 Beijing turned physical control of the shoal into a set of domestic legal facts: a measured territorial sea, a protected area, and a named enforcement agency. Each step answered a Philippine one.6 passages · 4 texts read08The 2002 Declaration, clause by clauseTen points signed in Phnom Penh, and how each is now usedThe Declaration on the Conduct of Parties is short, non-binding and still the only text all the claimants have signed with China. Almost every accusation in the dispute is phrased as a breach of one of its clauses.4 passages · 1 text read09Beijing's case against the award, in its own wordsThe arguments of 2016, and the ones Wang Yi added in 2025Beijing's objection is to the tribunal's right to hear the case at all. Its arguments about what the tribunal decided are fewer, later, and concentrated on one island.6 passages · 2 texts read10How the 2016 white paper tells the storyThe State Council's 143 paragraphs on the dispute with the PhilippinesThe white paper is Beijing's fullest narrative. Its structure is an argument: the islands were always China's, the Philippines created the dispute in the 1970s, both sides agreed to negotiate, and Manila broke that agreement.6 passages · 1 text read