South China Sea南海

Analysis

Coral as evidence: what the reef surveys find, and where

Six official survey reports on Huangyan Dao, Ren'ai Jiao, Xianbin Jiao, Tiexian Jiao and Niu'e Jiao, 2024 to 2026.

Since 2024 Chinese ministries have published a reef survey for almost every contested feature. Read together they form a pattern: reefs where the Philippines is present are found damaged by the Philippines, reefs where China is accused are found healthy, and one report settles a legal question about sandbars along the way.

The figures

FeatureFindingLive coral coverCause namedReport
Huangyan Dao (Scarborough Shoal)“Healthy”; water and sediment grade one; no cyanide28.6% (2024), 29.8% (2025); 38.8% in the reserve (2025 bulletin)Heat stress the main riskT51 T52 T56
Ren'ai Jiao (Second Thomas Shoal)Seriously damaged, worst near the shipNot given in the report as publishedThe grounded Philippine warship: rust, sewage, discarded netsT53
Xianbin Jiao (Sabina Shoal)“Healthy overall”; stable 2012–202424.7% average, 51.3% highestPhilippine coast guard ship's anchor and chain noted as harmT54
Tiexian Jiao (Sandy Cay)Severely degraded; coral area down about 68.9% from 2016 to 2024“Very low”Crown-of-thorns starfish mainly; cyclones; Philippine construction on Zhongye DaoT55
Niu'e Jiao (Whitsun Reef)“Healthy overall”; slow decline 2016–202437.7%Seasonal bleaching, fishing debrisT55

The reading

A survey for each flashpoint, timed to the dispute. The Ren'ai Jiao and Huangyan Dao reports appeared on 8 and 10 July 2024, in the week of the award's anniversary. The Xianbin Jiao report came out in August 2024 while a Philippine coast guard ship was anchored in the lagoon. The Tiexian Jiao report followed in April 2025, the month Chinese coast guard officers landed on the cay. Each is a scientific document released at a political moment. T53 T51 T54 T55 E65

The findings follow the map of control. At Huangyan Dao, which China controls, the reef is healthy and the water first grade. At Ren'ai Jiao, where a Philippine ship sits, the reef is badly damaged and the ship is the cause. At Xianbin Jiao and Tiexian Jiao, where Manila had accused China of dumping coral rubble, the reports find natural processes and call the accusations baseless. This does not show the science is wrong. It shows what the science is being asked to settle. T51 T53 T54 T55

Some findings cut against the simple story, and are reported anyway. The Tiexian Jiao report names an outbreak of crown-of-thorns starfish as the main cause of a 68.9% loss of coral area, with Philippine construction on nearby Zhongye Dao listed after cyclones as a further factor. The regional bulletin a year later repeats the same three causes in the same order. The report does not make the Philippines the main culprit where its own data point elsewhere. T55 T56

The cyanide sentence is there for a reason. Both Huangyan Dao reports state that no cyanide was detected in water, sediment or fish. The sentence answers a kind of accusation: in April 2026 the Foreign Ministry dismissed as a “self-staged farce” a Philippine claim that cyanide had been found in samples from Chinese boats near Ren'ai Jiao. The surveys put a laboratory result on record before the spokesperson needs one. T51 T52 E10

An ecology report makes a legal finding. The Tiexian Jiao report says the three sandbars there and one at Niu'e Jiao formed naturally and stand above water at high tide, and gives their heights above mean high water springs: between 1.10 and 1.47 metres. In the law of the sea a naturally formed feature above water at high tide can have a territorial sea; one that is submerged or artificial cannot. The measurement answers a claim that the sandbars were made by reclamation, and it also places a potential territorial sea within sight of Philippine-held Zhongye Dao. T55 S14

The surveys are themselves contested operations. The Xianbin Jiao team reports that Philippine boats monitored and interfered with its work for thirteen days and twice sent divers into the survey area, and that the China Coast Guard sent craft to protect it. Science at these reefs is done under escort. T54

From survey to reserve. The Huangyan Dao reports of 2024 and 2025 describe a healthy reef that can serve as a refuge for the sea's corals as waters warm. Between them the State Council approved a nature reserve at the shoal, and in 2026 its rules closed it to entry. The reports are the scientific record on which that legal step stands. T51 T52 S26 S30

The passages

Ren'ai Jiao report, July 2024

导致仁爱礁珊瑚礁生态系统遭到破坏的主要因素是菲律宾军舰非法“坐滩”及其相关联的人类活动。

The main factor in the damage to the coral reef ecosystem of Ren'ai Jiao is the illegal “grounding” of the Philippine warship and the human activity associated with it.

Huangyan Dao report, July 2024

海水、海洋沉积物和鱼类样品中均未检出氰化物

No cyanide was detected in samples of seawater, marine sediment or fish.

Xianbin Jiao report, August 2024

至于菲律宾炮制的所谓中国在仙宾礁人工堆积珊瑚碎屑导致该区域珊瑚大量白化死亡等言论,毫无科学和事实依据。

As for the claims concocted by the Philippines that China piled up coral rubble at Xianbin Jiao and caused mass bleaching and death of coral there, they have no scientific or factual basis whatever.

Tiexian Jiao and Niu'e Jiao report, April 2025

《报告》指出,铁线礁礁坪上现有3个沙洲,牛轭礁礁坪上现有1个沙洲,均属于自然形成,高潮时均出露海面

The Report states that there are at present three sandbars on the reef flat of Tiexian Jiao and one on the reef flat of Niu'e Jiao, all naturally formed and all above water at high tide.

Tiexian Jiao report

《报告》指出,长棘海星暴发是导致铁线礁珊瑚礁生态系统严重退化的主要因素

The Report states that an outbreak of crown-of-thorns starfish is the main factor in the severe degradation of the coral reef ecosystem at Tiexian Jiao.

South China Sea regional bulletin for 2025, August 2026

南沙岛礁生态状况分化明显,整体优良,个别岛礁生态系统受损退化严重。

The ecological condition of the Nansha features differs markedly: good overall, with the ecosystems of a few features seriously damaged and degraded.

← Thirty years of a fishing ban: conservation, enforcement and a line at 12°N “Add, subtract, divide, multiply”: a think-tank official explains the Huangyan Dao reserve →